Fans of Seeking Sister Wife are expressing strong opinions about Garrick Merrifield, going so far as to label him a “psychopath.” In the current season, Garrick is back with his wife, Dannielle Merrifield, as they embark on courting a new potential sister wife. But what has led fans to criticize Garrick so harshly? Let’s dive into the details.
Garrick Merrifield has always rubbed Seeking Sister Wife fans the wrong way. He entered the show claiming that God led him to pursue a plural lifestyle, despite already having marital issues with Dannielle. Initially, she was reluctant to open up their marriage, requiring extensive prayer before agreeing to start the search for a sister wife. They ultimately found a Brazilian woman named Roberta, but the circumstances surrounding their relationship raised suspicions. Garrick and Roberta were intimate, yet Dannielle was brought into the equation shortly afterward. Many fans felt that Roberta had manipulated and used the couple before abruptly leaving them.
Now, as Garrick and Dannielle return to the show, fans on Reddit are particularly vocal about their negative opinions of Garrick, even going so far as to call him a “psychopath.” One Reddit user detailed their issues with Garrick, including his manner of speaking and his fashion choices, clearly expressing their dislike for him. Other viewers who follow the show shared similar sentiments, expressing their concerns about Garrick’s behavior and its impact on Dannielle. Some fans even made humorous references, jokingly suggesting that he might be a lizard person or a con man.
It seems that Garrick Merrifield’s on-screen persona aligns with how he presents himself in real life. He firmly believes that he should have both his wife and a younger sister wife. However, if things don’t work out this time around, the Merrifields may consider ending their pursuit of a plural lifestyle. They had even built a polygamist mansion but have since put it up for sale. While Garrick may not be a favorite among fans, the buzz and discussions surrounding him contribute to his presence on the show.